BrandInsightAI Insights
Health · a live data story

Private Healthcare,
according to AI

Every week we ask ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini the questions real UK consumers ask about private healthcare — and record exactly which brands they put forward. Right now, Bupa owns the conversation.

0 AI answers this run · 0 brands named · measured, never estimated

The podium

Bupa is the default answer.

Named in 18% of private healthcare answers, typically in position 2.0. Circle Health Group follows at 17%, Spire Healthcare at 17%.

Circle Health Group
17% of answers
Bupa
18% of answers
Spire Healthcare
17% of answers
The full board

Every brand AI names, ranked.

Visibility is the share of answers naming the brand; citation share is its slice of all brand-owned pages cited; read→cited is how often its pages convert a read into a citation.

#BrandVisibilityAvg. positionCitation shareRead→cited
1Bupa 18% 2.0 5% 27%
2Circle Health Group 17% 1.9 9% 100%
3Spire Healthcare 17% 2.4 4% 14%
4Nuffield Health 15% 2.9 5% 100%
5AXA Health 15% 3.8 3% 33%
6Aviva 13% 5.0 0% 0%
7Practice Plus Group 10% 2.3 6% 40%
8HCA Healthcare 8% 3.2 3% 20%
9Portland Hospital 8% 3.2 0% —
10Vitality 8% 6.0 0% —
11RAMSAY HEALTH CARE 7% 3.8 1% —
12Lindo Wing 2% 1.0 0% —
13New Victoria Hospital 2% 2.0 2% 50%
14Newson Health 2% 3.0 1% —
15Cleveland Clinic London 2% 4.0 0% 0%
What AI wants here

Bupa is named most. That is not the same as being wanted.

Being named is visibility. Underneath it, asked to rate each brand directly, the AI assistants judge it three ways — how much it stands out, how much it belongs, and how much it is returned to. They put 48% of the 31 brands rated above indifference. Vitality leads the brands the answers name, at 75% of maximum Desire. On attraction, the most divided driver, Royal Marsden Private Care indexes 122 against Kinvara Private Hospital at 77, on a category average of 100.

Attraction
Royal Marsden Private Care122
Kinvara Private Hospital77
45-point spread
Attachment
Royal Marsden Private Care119
Kinvara Private Hospital76
43-point spread
Affinity
Royal Marsden Private Care117
Aspen Healthcare85
32-point spread
Vitality: Attraction 120, Affinity 101, Attachment 119
Vitality
Above indifference · Chosen, not loved
Bupa: Attraction 113, Affinity 107, Attachment 115
Bupa
Above indifference · Chosen, not loved
Cleveland Clinic London: Attraction 112, Affinity 109, Attachment 111
Cleveland Clinic London
Above indifference · Chosen, not loved
AttractionAffinityAttachment

Each whorl lights one ring per index threshold cleared (84 / 92 / 100 / 108 / 116). Above indifference means Desire above two-thirds of its maximum. See the AI Desire Index, market by market →

What AI searched for first

Before it answers, it goes looking for Spire Healthcare.

An assistant does not answer from memory alone. It runs its own web searches first, and whoever it searches for is the shortlist it then chooses from. Across 86 searches in private healthcare, Spire Healthcare is named in 33% of the ones that name a brand at all. ChatGPT Web does not report its searches, so these shares are measured against the ones that do.

Spire Healthcare 33%
AXA Health 22%
Bupa 22%
Circle Health Group 22%
Claude
Searches per question1.7
Names a brand0%
Names a year19%
Goes to a site0%
Gemini
Searches per question1.8
Names a brand15%
Names a year3%
Goes to a site0%
ChatGPT
Searches per question1.1
Names a brand0%
Names a year15%
Goes to a site55%
UK private health insurance routine diagnostic scans cover policy outpatient diagnostics insurer official
ChatGPT
site:moneyhelper.org.uk private medical insurance exclusions pre-existing conditions UK treatment
ChatGPT
UK private hospital room upgrade cost per night private room NHS hospital
ChatGPT
transparent self pay surgery pricing bundles UK private hospitals
Gemini

These are the assistants' own searches, read from their answers — not what anyone typed into a search engine.

Who AI trusts here

The referees of private healthcare.

The independent sources AI models cite when answering private healthcare questions — the places a brand needs to be seen, reviewed and ranked.

goingprivateuk.co.uk 23 cites
wecovr.com 13 cites
phin.org.uk 9 cites
allhealthandcare.co.uk 4 cites
comparemyhealthinsurance.co.uk 4 cites
cqc.org.uk 4 cites
lolahealth.com 4 cites
speedwellhealth.co.uk 4 cites
thebestofhealth.co.uk 4 cites
which.co.uk 4 cites
Read is not cited

Circle Health Group converts reads into citations. Spire Healthcare doesn't.

When Claude or ChatGPT opens a brand's own pages while answering, does the page make the cited-sources list? Circle Health Group converts 100% of reads; Spire Healthcare just 14%. That gap is a content problem, not a visibility problem.

Circle Health Group · read 5×100%
Practice Plus Group · read 10×40%
AXA Health · read 6×33%
Bupa · read 11×27%
HCA Healthcare · read 5×20%
Spire Healthcare · read 7×14%
Full data table
#BrandVisibilityAvg. positionCitation shareRead→cited
1Bupa18%2.05%27%
2Circle Health Group17%1.99%100%
3Spire Healthcare17%2.44%14%
4Nuffield Health15%2.95%100%
5AXA Health15%3.83%33%
6Aviva13%5.00%0%
7Practice Plus Group10%2.36%40%
8HCA Healthcare8%3.23%20%
9Portland Hospital8%3.20%—
10Vitality8%6.00%—
11RAMSAY HEALTH CARE7%3.81%—
12Lindo Wing2%1.00%—
13New Victoria Hospital2%2.02%50%
14Newson Health2%3.01%—
15Cleveland Clinic London2%4.00%0%
Which AI you ask

The models do not agree on who leads.

Ask about private healthcare and the brand you are shown depends on the assistant: Claude → Practice Plus Group, Gemini → Bupa, ChatGPT → Bupa. Their top-five lists share just 0% of names.

Claude recommends
Practice Plus Group
named in 15% of its answers
Gemini recommends
Bupa
named in 40% of its answers
ChatGPT recommends
Bupa
named in 15% of its answers

Brands whose visibility swings most between models — the bar per model, widest gap on the right.

Bupa 40pp
AXA Health 40pp
Aviva 40pp
Circle Health Group 30pp
Spire Healthcare 30pp
Nuffield Health 25pp
Vitality 25pp
RAMSAY HEALTH CARE 20pp
ClaudeGeminiChatGPT
The data behind this chart
BrandClaudeGeminiChatGPTSpread
Bupa0%40%15%40pp
AXA Health0%40%5%40pp
Aviva0%40%0%40pp
Circle Health Group10%35%5%30pp
Spire Healthcare10%35%5%30pp
Nuffield Health10%30%5%25pp
Vitality0%25%0%25pp
RAMSAY HEALTH CARE0%20%0%20pp
HCA Healthcare15%10%0%15pp
Portland Hospital15%10%0%15pp
What AI reads here

How-to guides carry private healthcare.

Every page AI opened while answering, classified by what kind of page it is. How-to guides supply the most citations; Comparisons convert best — 100% of the ones models opened were actually cited.

How-to guides
127 cited · 15 read only
89% of reads cited
Editorial
94 cited · 41 read only
70% of reads cited
pricing
60 cited · 5 read only
92% of reads cited
Product pages
48 cited · 4 read only
92% of reads cited
Comparisons
29 cited · 0 read only
100% of reads cited
Documentation
25 cited · 11 read only
69% of reads cited
Other
19 cited · 22 read only
46% of reads cited
category-page
17 cited · 0 read only
100% of reads cited
The data behind this chart
Page typeCitedRead but not citedConversion
How-to guides1271589%
Editorial944170%
pricing60592%
Product pages48492%
Comparisons290100%
Documentation251169%
Other192246%
category-page170100%
What gets cited

Structured data is what separates cited from ignored.

Of the private healthcare pages models actually opened, how much more often each feature's pages ended up in the cited sources. Structured data is worth 16 percentage points; cites its sources pages fare 59pp worse. Measured within the read population, so selection can't flatter it.

Structured data +16pp
Named author +1pp
Answer up front -2pp
Comparison table -4pp
Updated this year -13pp
Hard statistics -28pp
Cites its sources -59pp
The data behind this chart
FeaturePages withCited %Pages withoutCited %Difference
Structured data40784%15168%+16pp
Named author29180%26779%+1pp
Answer up front35079%20881%-2pp
Comparison table15977%39981%-4pp
Updated this year21072%34885%-13pp
Hard statistics9456%46485%-28pp
Cites its sources4025%51884%-59pp
Citation readiness

Practice Plus Group builds pages AI can quote.

Readiness scores each brand's own pages on the structure models reward — a direct answer up front, tables, hard numbers, named authors, structured data, recency, specifications. AXA Health is the widest gap: well-built pages that still aren't converting into citations.

BrandReadinessPages citedPages profiled
Practice Plus Group 55 44% 18
Cromwell Hospital 44 50% 6
Vitality 41 25% 4
Scan.com 33 67% 3
Benenden Hospital 31 27% 11
Cleveland Clinic London 29 50% 6
AXA Health 26 2% 103
Bupa 26 12% 136
Circle Health Group 25 8% 106
Aviva 23 2% 104

Readiness is the share of eight measurable structural signals present on a brand's profiled pages. It is a build-quality measure, not a ranking of the brand.

What the answers answer

The questions private healthcare pages have to settle.

Read straight off the pages AI cited: the consumer questions cited content answers most often. Content that fails to settle these is content models have no reason to quote.

What does private health insurance cover?
How does private health insurance work?
What is private health insurance?
How much does a private hip replacement cost in the UK?
What is private medical insurance (PMI)?
What is Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS)?
How much does a hip replacement cost in the UK?
How much does private surgery cost in the UK?
Keep exploring

Nineteen more categories.

Method: 20 unbranded consumer prompts per category, spread across the buying journey, run weekly against ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. Read→cited uses Claude and ChatGPT only (Gemini does not separate the two). Correlational observations of model behaviour at the time of the run. Data from the run completed Thu, 22 Oct 2026 06:07:26 GMT.

scroll ↓